FinQuest

Best brokerage accounts compared

The best brokerage account is the one that costs least for the way you invest, so this table compares Fidelity, Schwab, Vanguard, Robinhood, Interactive Brokers and other US brokers on what you pay to trade, hold and leave, what you can buy, and who holds your account if the broker fails.

In short

We compared 14 offers from 10 institutions on 18 criteria, with fees taken from their official price lists on October 26, 2026. Top of the ranking: Interactive Brokers, Webull, and Public.

Tariffs checked on · default ranking: Overall score · how scores are calculated

Only with:
Criteria shown 18/18
Fees
Investing
Platform and protection

Scores always count every criterion, hidden or not.

Click "Compare" on 2 or 3 offers to see them side by side.

Offer ranking

  1. 1

    Interactive Brokers

    18.5/20
    • Fees 4.5/5
    • Investing 4.7/5
    • Platform and protection 4.9/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $6.50$0 for stocks + 10 contracts at $0.65
    Yield on uninvested cash
    2.38%above the first $10,000 (Oct 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    6.38%benchmark + 2.5 pts (Oct 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $0
  2. 2

    Webull

    17.1/20
    • Fees 4.2/5
    • Investing 4/5
    • Platform and protection 5/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $0
    Yield on uninvested cash
    Variable rate shown in the app onlylower than Premium, raised above a net account value threshold
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    8.74%flat rate (Oct 16, 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $75
  3. 3

    Public

    16.4/20
    • Fees 4.4/5
    • Investing 3.2/5
    • Platform and protection 5/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $0
    Yield on uninvested cash
    3.30%High-Yield Cash Account (Sep 17, 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    5.15%up to $50,000 (Sep 17, 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $100
  4. 4

    Robinhood

    15.5/20
    • Fees 4.4/5
    • Investing 2.5/5
    • Platform and protection 5/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $0
    Yield on uninvested cash
    0%interest on cash is a Gold benefit (Oct 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    5.25%up to $50,000 (Sep 16, 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $100full or partial transfer
  5. 5

    Charles Schwab

    Brokerage account

    15.3/20
    • Fees 3.7/5
    • Investing 3.4/5
    • Platform and protection 5/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $6.50$0 for stocks + 10 contracts at $0.65
    Yield on uninvested cash
    0.01%uninvested brokerage cash (Oct 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    11.575%base rate 10.25% + 1.325 pts (since Sep 18, 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $50full transfer (partial is free)
  6. 6

    E*TRADE

    Brokerage account

    14.7/20
    • Fees 3.5/5
    • Investing 3.3/5
    • Platform and protection 5/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $6.50$0 for stocks + 10 contracts at $0.65
    Yield on uninvested cash
    0.01%Bank Deposit Program under $500,000 (Oct 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    12.20%base rate 10.20% + 2 pts (since Sep 21, 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $75full transfer
  7. 7

    Fidelity

    Brokerage account

    14.7/20
    • Fees 4/5
    • Investing 4.2/5
    • Platform and protection 1.6/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $6.50$0 for stocks + 10 contracts at $0.65
    Yield on uninvested cash
    About 3.49%SPAXX 7-day yield (Oct 2, 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    11.575%base rate 10.825% + 0.75 pt (since Sep 18, 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $0
  8. 8

    SoFi

    Active Investing

    13.9/20
    • Fees 4/5
    • Investing 4/5
    • Platform and protection 0.9/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $0
    Yield on uninvested cash
    No published rate on Invest cashSoFi savings is a separate bank account
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    9.50%up to $50,000 (2026 fee schedule)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $100
  9. 9

    Merrill Edge

    Self-Directed

    11.7/20
    • Fees 4.2/5
    • Investing 1.7/5
    • Platform and protection 1.6/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $6.50$0 for stocks + 10 contracts at $0.65
    Yield on uninvested cash
    0.01%Bank Deposit Program under $250,000 (Oct 23, 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    Merrill base lending rate (reset weekly) + spread by balancequoted by phone
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $49.95full transfer (partial is free)
  10. 10

    Vanguard

    Brokerage account

    10.6/20
    • Fees 3.1/5
    • Investing 3.3/5
    • Platform and protection 0/5
    Example: cost over a year
    $10$0 for stocks + 10 contracts at $1
    Yield on uninvested cash
    About 3.6%VMFXX 7-day SEC yield (Aug 2026)
    Margin rate ($25,000)
    11.75%base rate 9.75% + 2 pts (Oct 2026)
    Outgoing transfer fee (ACATS)
    $100full transfer or account closure

Informational, non-exhaustive comparison for educational purposes. Rates and fees come from each institution's official pages and fee schedules on the date shown and can change at any time: check with the institution before you open an account. This is not personalized financial advice.

How we compare brokerage accounts

The default sort uses one scenario for every broker: 12 online purchases of $500 of US stocks or ETFs and 10 equity option contracts in 2 orders of 5 over a year, membership fee included. Regulatory pass-through fees and margin interest are left out. Stock trades cost $0 almost everywhere, so the gap mostly comes from options fees and paid memberships.

The Fees section also covers account and transfer-out (ACATS) fees and the margin rate on a $25,000 loan. Investing looks at the default yield on uninvested cash, fractional shares, automatic investing, mutual funds, crypto and foreign markets. Platform and protection lists trading hours, apps and the broker-dealer that holds your account.

Which brokerage account is best for you?

  • Beginners and long-term investors. Look at fractional shares, automatic investing and the cash sweep yield. If you buy an ETF every month, commissions barely matter, but steady investing does: the dollar-cost averaging calculator shows what it adds up to.
  • Options traders. The default scenario is built for you: per-contract fees and memberships are already in it.
  • International investors. The foreign markets row shows who lets you trade on exchanges outside the US. Few US brokers keep clients who move abroad, so check the terms before you relocate.
  • Retirement savers. A taxable account is not always the best home for that money. Compare the best Roth IRA accounts too.

Hidden brokerage fees to watch

  • Idle cash. Some brokers sweep uninvested cash into a bank program paying a low rate. Others use a money market fund. On a few thousand dollars, the difference can cost more than every commission in the table.
  • Memberships. A paid tier can raise the cash yield or lower the margin rate. Do the math on your own balance before paying a yearly fee.
  • SIPC is not a market guarantee. If a member broker fails, SIPC protects up to $500,000 per customer, including a $250,000 limit for cash. It does not cover losses when your investments drop in value.
  • Margin. Rates are variable and high. A margin call can force a sale at the worst moment.

What the table does not tell you

The table does not rate research tools, order execution quality or how fast support answers. It also ignores the expense ratio of the funds you buy, which can cost more than trading over the years. To see that effect, try the expense ratio calculator.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best brokerage account for beginners?

There is no single winner: look for a broker with no minimum to open, fractional shares, automatic investing and an app you find easy. Then sort the table by yearly cost and cash sweep yield, the two rows that matter most on a small portfolio.

How much money do I need to open a brokerage account?

At most large online brokers, nothing: a standard brokerage account has no minimum deposit. With fractional shares you can buy an ETF with a few dollars. A margin account usually requires a minimum balance.

Can I open a US brokerage account if I am not a citizen?

Yes, if you live in the US: you usually need an SSN or ITIN, a US address and a government ID. If you live outside the US, most brokers in the table will turn you down. Interactive Brokers is one of the few that opens accounts for residents of many countries.

If stock trades are free, how do brokers make money?

Mostly from interest on your uninvested cash, margin loans, options fees, paid memberships and payment for order flow. That is why the cash yield and margin rate rows matter as much as the commission row.

Can I move my account to another broker?

Yes. An ACATS transfer moves your holdings without selling them, so you do not trigger a taxable sale. Your old broker may charge an outgoing fee, shown in the table, and some new brokers reimburse it. Fractional shares and proprietary funds sometimes have to be sold first.

Is a brokerage account the right place for retirement savings?

A taxable brokerage account has no contribution limit and no withdrawal rules, but you pay tax on dividends and gains each year you realize them. An IRA or a 401(k) gives a tax break in exchange for limits and rules. Many people use both.

How are the scores calculated?

Each criterion is scored from 0 to 5 against the other offers in the table, each section is the mean of its criteria, and the overall score is the mean of the sections scaled to 20, with fees weighing more than the rest.

Other comparisons

All comparisons All calculators